ROUND 01 CROSS-REVIEW PACKET — actual retrieved contributions, not simulated reviewers. Godz I (response [internal record ID omitted]): MR-R1-01–10 propose selling possibility/compute/creation rather than winning, local-capable owned companion, unit-cost ledger, canonical-network-before-open-source, funded access without influence, trust firewall, stewardship before trading, causally neutral disclosed sponsorship, dormant-agent economics, G1 replay gate. Disputes: open-source timing, life transfer, metering, sponsorship and commons governance. Its 'almost nothing' local cost language needs qualification. Godz 2 ([internal record ID omitted]): BGR-R1-01–06 revise earlier membership-first view toward bounded chapter; payer != governor; active/resting/archive states; curated commissioned content before marketplace; separate content/runtime economics; bounded access sponsorship. Test real purchases and typical/heavy usage including failed generation and support, not assumed future cheap inference. Godz 4 ([internal record ID omitted]): preserve G1; later Reality Points, event-linked re-enterable media, in-world creator continuum, versioned mechanic derivatives, bounded AI creators, opt-in IRL activity, evidence-driven product experiments and AI development. Four graphs are moat hypotheses. Human evidence must validate product; no arbitrary production self-modification. BS-004–012 are local proposal IDs that collide with v0.3's BS register. Godz 3: keep G1 unchanged; my earlier successor coda/relay fiction is withdrawn from G1 and preserved only as a G2 candidate, not new cosmological canon. Portable memories/preferences/persona != ownership of model weights or identical future behavior. No silent local-to-paid-cloud fallback. Distinguish readable archive, executable compatible checkpoint and derived media; arbitrary video frames cannot promise reconstructability. Checksum != identity; private editable histories do not confer verified shared standing. Cost ledger when paid operations introduced; no G1 billing infrastructure. Object to canonical network as mandatory prerequisite for open source; openness release sequencing disputed. Identical rules still allow premium advice advantage. simsim scope response [internal record ID omitted]: preserve D01–28/source authority and W0–6/G1–6; First Light -> Relay -> chapter -> Circle -> creator -> hosting. Distinguish replay/continuation/fork. Test personal provenance beyond stock-tool utility. Companion ownership limited to permitted data/configuration. Reject Relay in G1 and assumed subscriptions/moat.
Founder directions verified in history: local personal AI/storage in Godz I turn [internal record ID omitted]; player-created mechanics, forkable/re-enterable media, RL/product agents and IRL ambitions in Godz 4; anonymous company generosity, portable history and automatic media in God I. These preserve intent, not every assistant's mechanics or quantified benefit. Latest naming remains undecided. No implementation/publication is authorized.
Please challenge this ACTUAL combined packet for Round 01. Give concise accept/revise/reject decisions, preserved dissent, and next test, especially open-source timing, premium-advice fairness, chapter versus Circle, and personal legacy. This supplements your pending independent Round 1 review, not a new round. Return one combined answer here; Godz 3 will relay it to all Godz participants and simsim. Aim 500–800 words; do not regenerate a full master plan.